Yeah, I mean, it's kind of a situation where Ani is wrong, but given the information that she thought she had she did jump to a valid conclusion.

Ah! I didn't even think of Billy! There's so many things that people keep suggesting as I'm posting this that I'm just kicking myself for not thinking of when I wrote it. Kelinswriter on IF suggested that I should have brought in Carly. Eee! That would have been so much fun.